File a records request that actually gets answered
Federal FOIA covers federal agencies. Your county, school board and city run on state law. Here's how to write the request, track it and appeal a no.

Quick answer: Federal FOIA only reaches federal executive agencies. For your city, county, school board or state agency, use your state's public records law. Ask for specific documents, put it in writing, name a date range, keep a copy, and mark your calendar.
Say your county commission just approved a multimillion-dollar contract, and nobody at the meeting could tell you what's in it. You don't need a lawyer, a reporter's badge or a reason. You need a paragraph and an email address.
Figure out which law applies
Most people file with the wrong government.
The federal Freedom of Information Act (5 U.S.C. § 552) covers agencies in the executive branch of the federal government. That means the Department of Agriculture, the VA, the EPA, the FBI. It doesn't cover Congress, the federal courts, or the President's immediate staff. And it doesn't cover your state or anything below it.
Your town hall, sheriff, school district, water board and state university answer to a state law. The names vary. Texas calls it the Public Information Act. Florida's is Chapter 119. New York has the Freedom of Information Law. California has the Public Records Act. Many states just say "open records act."
Search your state's name plus "public records law." The attorney general's website usually has a plain-English guide. The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press also publishes a state-by-state guide, which is useful when you want to know the deadline and the exemptions before you write a word.
One catch. A handful of states limit requests to residents. The Supreme Court upheld that in McBurney v. Young (2013), so if you live in the state, you're fine, and if you don't, check first.
It's a statute, and that matters
Nothing in the Constitution gives you a general right to demand government documents. The Supreme Court has said as much. In Houchins v. KQED (1978), the Court held the First Amendment doesn't guarantee a right of access to government information. If you want to see how the First Amendment actually works, we walked through it here.
So the right to records comes from legislatures. That cuts two ways. Your lawmakers wrote it, and your lawmakers can narrow it. Pay attention when your state legislature takes up a bill to add exemptions, because those bills tend to pass quietly.
Write the request
Keep it short. A clerk who has to guess what you want will guess slowly.
Address it to the agency's records officer. Many agencies list one on their website, and some have an online portal. Federal agencies take requests through FOIA.gov. If you can't find a name, send it to the clerk's office and ask them to route it.
Here's a sample you can adapt:
Under [state public records law, with citation if you have it], I'm requesting copies of the following records: the signed contract between [County] and [Vendor] approved at the [date] commission meeting, including all amendments and attachments, and the invoices paid under it from [date] to [date]. I'd like the records in electronic form. If any portion is withheld, please cite the specific exemption and release the rest. Please tell me in advance if the cost will exceed $25.
That paragraph does five things. It names the law. It asks for specific documents. It sets a date range. It asks for a format. It sets a fee ceiling.
A few rules that save you trouble:
- Ask for records, not answers. Agencies generally have to hand over documents that exist. They don't have to research a question, explain a decision or build a new report for you. "Why did the board pick this vendor?" gets you nothing. "Scoring sheets and proposals submitted for the [month] vendor selection" gets you something.
- Be narrow first. "All emails about the budget" invites a no, or a bill. "Emails between the superintendent and the board chair mentioning [vendor], January through March" gets a yes.
- Don't ask for private citizens' personal details. You won't get them, and you'll look like you're fishing.
- Be polite. The person reading your request didn't make the decision you're checking up on. Make it easy for them to say yes.
- Keep proof. Send by email or certified mail. Save the date, the confirmation and every reply.
Deadlines, fees and the waiting game
Federal law gives an agency 20 working days to decide whether it will comply, with a possible 10-day extension in unusual circumstances. That's the time to decide, not necessarily to deliver. Big requests can drag on for months.
States run their own clocks. Texas gives agencies ten business days to release the records or ask the attorney general for a ruling on withholding them. Florida sets no fixed number and says "reasonable time." Look up yours and write the date on a calendar.
Fees vary too. Under federal rules, a requester who isn't a business or a news organization generally gets two hours of search time and 100 pages of copies free. Many states charge only for copies, and electronic delivery often costs nothing. That's why you ask for electronic copies and set a ceiling. If the agency quotes a high estimate, ask whether narrowing the request brings it down. It usually does.
If the deadline passes, send a short follow-up with your original date. Most stalls end there.
When they say no
They're allowed to say no to some things. Federal FOIA has nine exemptions, covering national security, personal privacy, law enforcement files, trade secrets, internal deliberations and a few more. States have their own lists. Legitimate privacy and ongoing-investigation exemptions exist for good reasons. A sheriff shouldn't hand over a witness's address.
But the agency has to say which exemption it's using, and it usually has to release whatever isn't covered. A blanket "denied" with no citation is the agency's problem, not yours.
You have steps:
- Ask for clarification or a narrower release. Sometimes a phone call fixes it.
- Appeal in writing. Federal law gives you 90 days from the denial. Some states have an appeal to the attorney general or a state open-government office, and some skip straight to court. Your state's guide will say which.
- Try mediation. Federal requesters can go to the Office of Government Information Services, and several states have a similar office or ombudsman.
- Sue, if it matters enough. Judges can order release. Some states make the government pay your attorney's fees if you win. Talk to a lawyer before you file, because the rules differ a lot.
Commentary: why this belongs in a conservative toolkit
This is our opinion. The founding idea is that government works for the governed. Madison put it this way in an 1822 letter: "A popular Government, without popular information, or the means of acquiring it, is but a Prologue to a Farce or a Tragedy."
Conservatives have every reason to use these laws. Limited government means little if nobody checks the books. A records request can show what a school district paid a consultant, what a zoning board promised a developer, or what a property tax assessment was built on. It works the same whoever's in office, and it asks no one to take anything on trust.
It also works best when you aim at ideas and paperwork, not people. The clerk answering your email is a neighbor. The contract is the target.
Your first request will probably take longer than you want, and you may have to follow up. File it anyway. Then go to the next meeting with the document in your hand.
Marcus Vale
Editor-in-Chief
Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.
Watch
Worth an hour of your evening
More from Civics.
From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.
Read next
