Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Tie Your First Trout Fly at the Kitchen Table

A vise, a spool of thread and a pinch of feathers will get you a fly that actually catches fish. Here's what to buy, tie and avoid.

By Dean Shaw · Gear & Garage5 min read
hobbies section

Quick answer: Buy a decent starter kit or a basic vise and a short list of materials. Tie a Woolly Bugger, a Zebra Midge and a Pheasant Tail this week. Expect ugly flies at first. Trout aren't picky about ugly.

Let's get the honest part out of the way. Tying your own flies will not save you money, at least not for the first year. A store-bought fly costs a couple of dollars. You'll spend ten times that on gear before you finish your first dozen.

That's not why people do it.

Why people get hooked

Somewhere around your fifth fly, it clicks. You're sitting at a desk under a lamp, wrapping a bit of pheasant feather around a hook the size of a fingernail clipping, and an hour disappears. It's quiet, it's precise, and nobody needs anything from you.

Then comes the part you can't buy. You tie a fly in January, tuck it in a box, and in April a trout takes it. You made that. A fish ate your work.

It's also a better way to fish. When the stream's trout are eating size 18 midges and the shop is sold out, you tie your own at 9 p.m. and you're ready by sunrise. And it keeps a man or woman busy through the long off-season, with something real to show for it.

If you like working with your hands, you'll feel at home here. It's in the same family as leatherworking: small tools, patient steps, a finished object you can hold. And like a model railroad, it fits on one corner of a table.

What it really costs to start

These are ballpark figures. Prices move, so check a fly shop or catalog before you buy.

  • A vise. This holds the hook while you work. A solid beginner vise usually runs somewhere around forty to eighty dollars. Griffin and Dr. Slick make dependable entry-level models. Skip the very cheapest ones, because a hook that slips mid-wrap will make you want to quit.
  • Basic tools. You need fine scissors, a bobbin to hold the thread, a whip finish tool and a bodkin (a needle in a handle) for applying head cement. Dr. Slick scissors are a common first pair. Figure thirty to sixty dollars for the lot.
  • Materials. Hooks, thread, chenille, wire, beads, marabou, hackle and pheasant tail. A first round of materials for three patterns is often another forty to sixty dollars.

All told, plan on roughly a hundred and twenty to two hundred dollars to be properly set up. A boxed starter kit from a company like Orvis or Hareline can bundle much of this for less than buying piece by piece. The tools in a kit are usually fine for a beginner, though you'll upgrade the scissors first.

Two cautions. Don't buy a thousand-dollar vise because a forum told you to. And don't buy every material you see. Beginners who stock forty colors of dubbing tie nothing for a month.

The first three things to do this week

1. Set up a spot. A small table, a lamp you can angle, and a plain light-colored towel or tray under the vise to catch dropped feathers and hooks. A dropped hook on a carpet finds a bare foot. Keep hooks away from small children and pets, and keep a lidded container for loose ones.

2. Tie a Woolly Bugger. This is the starter fly for a reason. It uses a streamer hook (size 8 or 10), black thread, a marabou tail, black chenille for the body and a saddle hackle wrapped up the body. Trout eat it as a leech, a minnow or a hellgrammite. It's forgiving, and a messy one still works.

3. Tie a Zebra Midge and a Pheasant Tail nymph. The midge is a size 18 hook, black thread, a silver wire rib and a tiny bead. It teaches you thread control. The Pheasant Tail uses pheasant tail fibers, copper wire and a bit of peacock herl for the thorax. It's one of the most trusted nymphs in the sport. Between the three, you've learned most of the basic moves.

Watch a few good tying videos before and while you tie. A pattern is much easier to copy when you can see the hands. Pause often and rewind.

The mistakes everyone makes

Using too much material. Beginner flies come out fat and shaggy. A fly dressed too heavy looks like a cotton ball and fishes badly. When you think you've got enough, remove half.

Crowding the eye. Leave a gap behind the hook eye. If your head is jammed against it, you can't thread your tippet through later. Tie it, check the eye, and cut off anything blocking it.

Loose thread tension. If wraps spin around the hook, you're not pulling snug enough. If the thread snaps, you're pulling too hard. You'll find the middle after a dozen flies. Use a light, steady pull.

Skipping the whip finish. A fly that unravels on its first fish is a lesson in humility. Learn the whip finish early, even if you use a tool. Add a drop of head cement to seal it.

Starting with tiny hooks. Size 22 midges look cool and make grown adults swear. Start with an 8 or 10 where you can see what you're doing, and work down.

Judging by looks. Your first flies will look rough. Fish them anyway. The trout doesn't read the magazine.

Finding your people

You can learn alone, and plenty do. But a tying night teaches faster than any video, because someone leans over and says, "Stop right there, you're wrapping backwards."

  • Local fly shops. Many host tying nights or winter tying benches, often free. Walk in, say you're new and ask. Shop folks like beginners who buy a spool of thread and ask real questions.
  • Trout Unlimited chapters. TU has chapters across the country, and many run tying nights through the cold months. They also do stream cleanup days, which is a good way to meet people who care about the water.
  • Fly Fishers International clubs. Search their site for a club near you. Many run beginner classes and put on fly-fishing shows with tying demonstrations.
  • Libraries and outdoor stores. Some host a tying clinic in winter, so check bulletin boards and event pages.

Bring a few of your flies, however ugly. Nobody there will laugh. Every person in that room tied a Woolly Bugger that looked like roadkill.

When you do get to the river, return the favor. Show up early. Offer a spare fly to the guy who left his box in the truck. Leave the bank cleaner than you found it. That's how the sport has always worked.

Tie three flies this week. Put them in a box. Then go find a trout.

Dean Shaw

Gear & Garage

Reads the warranty, the parts list and the long-term owner reviews before anything else. Trucks, tools, watches, and the cheap version that costs more.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Hobbies.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Patrick Plays PickleballSep 10

    7 "Boring" Pickleball Tips Every Senior Player Needs To Use

    All Things PickleballDec 17

    10 Pickleball Tips I Wish I Knew When I First Started (that no one talks about!!!!)

    That Pickleball Trainer - Connor DerricksonNov 17

    How Often Should you Play Pickleball

    Ashley GriffithJun 18

    10 Things I Wish I Knew When I Started Pickleball