Skip to content
BRO TakeEvergreen guide

Your wife's one-liners beat any comedy special you've seen

A pro writes a year for strangers. She's had fifteen years of material on you. Here's why she wins, and how to lose gracefully.

By Marcus Vale · Editor-in-Chief5 min read
Your wife's one-liners beat any comedy special you've seen

Quick answer: Stand-up is written for strangers. Her lines are written for you, by someone with years of firsthand footage. Laugh first, concede out loud, and steal the method.

"I'll have the shelf up by Saturday."

"Which Saturday?"

Three words. No comedy special has a better laugh per word, and you know it, because you were standing there holding a level and a bad attitude when she said it.

She has the material

A professional comedian spends a year building an hour. He tests it in half-empty rooms, trims it, and tries it on people who know nothing about him. Everything in the act has to be explained, because the audience just met him.

Your wife skipped all that. She's been taking notes since the wedding. She knows you said the project would need "one quick trip" to the hardware store. She knows you've owned the same unfinished project for two summers. She knows exactly how you sound when you say "I know where I'm going."

That's why generic jokes about husbands never land like hers do. "Men can't find anything in the fridge" gets a polite chuckle. "It's on the second shelf, where it was the first two times you looked" gets a laugh from everybody and a long look at the floor from you.

Specific beats clever. Every time.

She doesn't need a setup

Setup is the tax comedians pay for not knowing the room. Your wife knows the room. It's a kitchen, it's Tuesday, and you're the only other person in it.

So she skips straight to the line, and the line is short. Four words, maybe six. Then she does the part that separates the amateurs from the pros. She stops talking.

That silence is doing more work than any punchline, which is a whole subject of its own in The Pause Is Doing More Work Than Your Punchline. She lets you hear yourself. By the time you've replayed what you said, you've written her punchline for her, and her timing has worked on you for free.

There's something true inside it

Read the great ones back and you'll find a true thing in the middle.

"Which Saturday?" works because there have been several Saturdays. "You're not lost, you're exploring" works because you were, in fact, lost. The joke is a small, accurate observation delivered with a smile. You wince and laugh in the same half second, and that's how you know it was good.

It also only works with affection underneath. A zinger is a tap on the shoulder, not a punch. When it comes from contempt, it isn't a zinger anymore. It's a different conversation, and you should hear it as one. If a line keeps landing in the same sore spot, the spot is the subject, and the laugh is optional.

The other ninety-nine lines out of a hundred are just two people who know each other well. Enjoy those.

How to take one

Most men lose these exchanges twice. First to the line, then to the response. Fix the response.

  • Laugh first. A real one, out loud. A delayed laugh sounds like a man checking whether he's allowed.
  • Concede. "That's fair." Two words, and you've gained more ground than any comeback could.
  • Skip the counterpunch unless it's better. A weak return makes hers look even sharper. If you've got a great one, fire away. If you're searching, you don't.
  • Don't explain yourself. Explaining a joke kills it. Explaining why you deserved it kills you.
  • Tell it at dinner, and give her credit. This is the real move.

The man who loses the story wins the table

Pay attention at the next family dinner. The guy telling a story where he's the hero gets polite attention. The guy telling a story where his wife dismantled him in four words gets the whole table, the kids, and an uncle who'll repeat it at Thanksgiving.

You become the funniest person present by being the best audience she has. And she gets the credit she's earned, which does more for a marriage than a bouquet.

One rule on this. She's always the sharp one in the story, never the punchline. Tell the one where she wins. Don't tell the one that makes her small, and be careful about telling any of them when she's out of earshot and the room is full of strangers. Done right, it's a toast. Done wrong, it's gossip with a laugh track.

Then steal the method

You don't have to be her. You can borrow how she works.

Say something specific, and bring a real detail instead of a type. "I'm a terrible cook" is nothing. "I once set off the smoke detector making toast" is a story.

Keep it short, and cut the first half of whatever you were about to say. Put a true thing in the middle. And aim it at yourself first, with affection, the way she aims hers at you. You can take your own shots. They're the safest ones in the house.

Do this for a few weeks and something nice happens. The lines start to stick. "Which Saturday?" becomes a phrase the whole family uses, and the kids ask each other the same thing about homework. That's an inside joke doing its quiet work in the walls of your house, the kind of thing The Inside Joke Is Load-Bearing is about. And if you've ever assembled furniture together, you've already been living in the material, as The Twelve Stages of Building a Dresser With Your Wife can confirm.

The comedy special can wait

Go ahead and watch the specials. Some are very good, and a few are even clean. But the best writing you'll hear this year won't be on a stage. It'll come from the other side of the kitchen island, over the sound of you looking for something that's right in front of you.

The shelf went up Friday. She looked at it for a while and said nothing at all.

Best line she's ever had.

Marcus Vale

Editor-in-Chief

Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Humor.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Focus on the FamilyApr 16

    Deep Thoughts on Dumb Things | Clean Comedy with John Branyan

    Greg Dean's Stand-Up Comedy ClassesJan 23

    🎤3 Types of Joke Setups - How to Write Jokes - Greg Dean Stand Up Comedy Classes #comedians #joke

    Jerry Corley aka The Joke DoctorSep 20

    How to Tell a Joke [ SECRET ]

    Craig ValentineFeb 8

    Use Humor in Speaking without Telling Jokes | 1 Powerful Public Speaking Technique