Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Read the dateline before you read the story

Two words in capital letters tell you whether the reporter saw it, heard about it, or read about it. Here's how to use them.

By Marcus Vale · Editor-in-Chief5 min read
Read the dateline before you read the story

Quick answer: A dateline is a claim about where the reporting happened. Check it against who the story says saw what. When the dateline, the verbs and the sourcing don't line up, trust the story less.

In 2003, The New York Times published a long, painful account of its own reporter Jayson Blair. He had filed stories datelined from places like Maryland and Texas. Much of the time he was nowhere near them. The scenes he described were borrowed, assembled or invented from a desk.

Nobody caught it by reading the prose. The prose was fine. What gave him away was a handful of facts that didn't check out, and a dateline that said "I was there" when he wasn't.

That's the lesson. The two or three words in capitals at the start of a story are the cheapest piece of verification you'll ever get, and almost nobody reads them.

What a dateline promises

By convention, the city at the top of a news story tells you where the reporting was done. A story headed WASHINGTON (AP) says the news is tied to Washington and a reporter or editor in that place stands behind it. A story from a small-town paper datelined with the county seat usually means somebody drove there and stood in the room.

It's a convention, not a legal guarantee. Outlets handle it differently, and many add a note at the bottom: "contributed reporting from," or on wire copy, a line listing who reported from where and who wrote it from where. That line is worth reading. It's often the honest map of the story.

No dateline at all usually means a desk wrote it. That's not sinister. A reporter in an office can summarize a court filing perfectly well. But a story with no dateline can't claim the weight of an eyewitness.

Sort every sentence into three bins

Take any story from a hot spot and sort what it says into three piles:

  • Saw it. The reporter describes what they personally observed, in their own voice.
  • Was told. Someone said it: an official, a witness, a spokesman. The verb gives it away. "Said," "claimed," "according to."
  • Read it. The reporter is relaying a document, a statement, a post or another outlet's reporting.

Most stories from conflict zones, disaster areas and capitals are mostly the second and third piles with a little of the first for color. That's not a scandal. It's just what the dateline can and can't support.

A reporter datelined in a city under bombardment can personally verify what they can see from their street. They usually can't verify what happened across town, let alone across the country. Treat the wide claims as relayed claims, because that's what they are.

When the place is real but the access isn't

Being in a place doesn't mean seeing it. In the early 1930s, Walter Duranty reported for the Times from Moscow and won a Pulitzer for his coverage. His dispatches played down the famine then devastating Ukraine. Soviet authorities controlled where foreign reporters could go and who they could meet. Gareth Jones, a Welsh journalist, walked through Ukrainian villages on his own and reported what he found. The Moscow dateline carried the prestige. The man who actually went to the villages had the facts.

The same pattern shows up today in smaller forms. Check the story for these phrases:

  • "Reporters were taken to..." means an escorted tour. You're seeing what the host wants seen.
  • "In a pool report" or "pool reporter" means one journalist stood in for many, and everybody else is working from that one pair of eyes.
  • "Embedded with" means the unit let them in. They'll see real things from one side of a line.
  • "Could not independently verify" is a plain admission. Believe it. Then notice how many headlines didn't carry it.

None of these make the reporting worthless. An embedded reporter's account of a firefight is valuable. It's just one angle, and the story should say so.

The case where the fast version was wrong

In October 2023, a blast at the Al-Ahli hospital in Gaza killed many people, and early headlines in a number of major outlets pointed to an Israeli airstrike. The source for that was the Hamas-run health ministry. Reporters couldn't walk into the compound and check. Within days, U.S. and other Western assessments said the evidence pointed to a misfired Palestinian rocket, and The New York Times published an editors' note saying its early coverage had leaned too heavily on claims it couldn't verify.

Read the early stories again with the three bins in mind. The claim came from a party to the war. The reporters weren't at the site when it happened. The attribution was in the text, but the headline flattened it into fact. You didn't need to know who was right on day one. You needed to see that the story was "was told," dressed up as "saw it."

This cuts every direction. A government can brief a reporter with a claim that can't be checked. So can a rebel group, a campaign, a company or a ministry. Datelines don't care who is talking. Neither should you.

Run the check in thirty seconds

Next time a story makes you angry or pleased, do this before you share it:

  1. Read the dateline. Where does the story say it was reported from?
  2. Read the last lines. Look for contributor credits and notes about where else the reporting happened.
  3. Underline the verbs. Count how many are "said" and how many are "saw."
  4. Check the headline against the body. Does the headline state as fact something the body only attributes?
  5. Look for the correction link. Outlets that own their mistakes make them easy to find. Our guide on how to tell which outlets actually own their mistakes covers what to look for.

If the story rests on sources you can't see, when an anonymous source is worth believing is the next step. And if you want the whole routine an editor runs, start with the four questions an editor asks before a story runs.

Where this gets abused

Commentary shows and opinion sites often skip all this. A host broadcasting from a studio isn't pretending to be at the scene, and that's fine. But when they describe a scene as if they'd witnessed it, you're hearing someone else's reporting at second or third hand. Ask who did the seeing.

It also runs the other way. A reader who sees a dateline and assumes the story must be solid is making the same mistake as one who sees a source they dislike and assumes it must be false. Both have decided without checking. A dateline in a famous city proves where a keyboard was. It doesn't prove what anybody saw.

Some of the best reporting you'll read has a dull dateline from a place you've never heard of. Somebody went there, stood in a courtroom or a kitchen, and wrote down what happened.

Look for the person who was there, and then listen to what they say they actually saw.

Marcus Vale

Editor-in-Chief

Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Media Literacy.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    MediaWiseJan 25

    Media literacy masterclass with MediaWise Campus Correspondents

    Decibel from Austin PBSMar 15

    How can you fact check the internet?

    FaktabaariMar 17

    Fact-checking and Digital Information Literacy

    EdutopiaMay 28

    A Media Literacy Tool to Assess News Credibility