Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

The dog at your table is being paid by your kids

Counter surfing and begging aren't a dog problem. They're a payroll problem, and a few weeks of house rules fixes most of it.

By Wes Dunbar · Country & Skills6 min read
The dog at your table is being paid by your kids

Quick answer: Stop the payouts first, then teach the dog where to be. Clear the counter edges, make "nobody feeds the dog from a plate" a house rule for the kids, and give the dog a mat and a chew at dinner. Expect two to four weeks of boring consistency.

The dog isn't broken

Picture a Lab under a high chair. A two-year-old drops a piece of toast. Then drops another, on purpose, watching the dog. The dog's ears go up. Dad says "no" without looking up from his phone. Thirty seconds later, a seven-year-old slides a chicken nugget off her plate and under the table, thinking nobody saw.

Your dog saw. He's been paid three times this dinner, and a dog paid at random is the most persistent employee you'll ever have. It's the slot machine principle. A machine that pays every tenth pull gets pulled all night. A machine that never pays gets abandoned.

So the dog isn't disobedient. He's doing a very good job at the wrong job. Your task is to close that job down and open a better one.

Fix the house before you train the dog

Training a dog to ignore a rib roast while the rib roast sits on the edge of the counter is a fight you'll lose about one time in five. And one time in five is exactly the payout rate that keeps the habit alive.

Management comes first, and it's cheap:

  • Push everything back from the counter edge. Eight inches is a reasonable start for a big dog.
  • Put bread, butter, and anything in a wrapper in a cabinet or the microwave, not beside the toaster.
  • Get a trash can with a lid that latches, or put it behind a door.
  • Don't leave a cooling plate, a cutting board, or a pizza box unattended in a room the dog can reach. Close a door or use a baby gate.

Concede the obvious here. If you own a Great Dane or a tall Lab with a long neck, the counter is within his reach for life, and some management will be permanent. That's fine. Management plus training beats training alone.

Make the kids the first line of defense

This is the part most dog advice skips, because it's awkward. Your children are the leak.

Kids don't feed dogs out of malice. They do it because the dog looks sad, because it feels generous, or because the nugget was gross. A rule works better than a lecture. Use one sentence, the same every night: "The dog eats from the dog bowl."

Then make it easy to obey:

  • Give the kids a job. The seven-year-old fills the dog's bowl at a set time, every day. It's a real responsibility and it puts her on the right side of the rule.
  • Feed the dog before the family sits down, or during. A dog that's already eating his own dinner isn't staring at yours.
  • For toddlers, the dog goes on his mat or behind a gate during meals. A toddler can't follow rules yet. That's your job, not the toddler's.
  • Back the rule with a real consequence for the humans. If a plate gets fed to the dog, the dog leaves the room and the kid hears about it calmly. No yelling. Just the dog going out, every time.

You'll also have to hold the line with the adults. Grandpa slipping bacon under the table undoes a month of work in one visit. Tell him kindly and plainly, before he arrives. He'll survive it.

Teach "place," not just "leave it"

"Leave it" earns its keep, but it's a negative. The dog has to keep resisting, and resisting is work. "Place" gives him a job he can win at.

If you haven't done basic obedience yet, start with Sit, Stay and Come in Fifteen Minutes a Day, because place builds on a solid stay.

Here's the sequence:

  1. Pick a mat or a bed in the corner of the kitchen or dining room, out of the traffic lanes.
  2. Lure the dog onto it with a treat. The moment all four paws are on it, say "yes" and give the treat on the mat.
  3. Add the word "place" as he steps on. Feed him on the mat for a few seconds, then release him with a word like "free."
  4. Build the time slowly. Five seconds, then fifteen, then a minute. Step back a pace, then two.
  5. Add a long-lasting chew, like a stuffed rubber toy, once he's holding it for a few minutes. Chew time on the mat equals dinner time.

Run it at non-dinner times first, with no food on the table. Short sessions of five minutes, a couple times a day. Then move it to real dinners. Expect him to pop up at first. Calmly walk him back. No scolding. Every successful minute on the mat is one he wasn't practicing begging.

What to do when he's already on the counter

If you catch him with his feet up, don't chase him or shout. A chase is a game, and chase games pay in attention.

Say nothing, put him on the floor, and reward him for being there. Quietly drop a treat on the floor while he stands with four paws down. Four on the floor is the behavior you're paying for. It sounds backwards, rewarding a dog who was just caught, but you're rewarding the floor, not the crime.

Then go back to the management list. If he got up there once, something edible was within reach. Move it.

The foods that make this a safety issue

Most scraps are only a weight problem. A few can put a dog in the emergency room, which is why the kids' rule matters more than it looks.

Dogs shouldn't eat chocolate, grapes or raisins, onions or garlic, macadamia nuts, or anything sweetened with xylitol (some peanut butters and sugar-free gum and baked goods contain it). Cooked bones can splinter. Very fatty scraps, like bacon grease or the fat trimmed off a roast, can trigger a painful inflammation of the pancreas in some dogs.

If your dog gets into any of it, don't wait to see how he does. Call your veterinarian or an emergency vet right away and tell them what he ate, about how much, and when. Your vet is also the person to ask how many treats and extras your particular dog can have in a day. Many vets suggest keeping treats to a small slice of daily calories, but the right number depends on the dog. If scraps have already put weight on him, what the dog food bag is actually telling you is a good place to start recalibrating his real meals.

Give it a month

The first month goes like this. Week one, the dog tests everything, because the machine used to pay and he wants to be sure it's really broken. Week two is worse, a classic extinction burst, where he tries harder before he quits. Don't give in at the worst moment. That one payout resets the clock.

By week three, most dogs settle on the mat with a chew. By week four, the kids have forgotten they ever fed him under the table, and a plate left at a child's height is just a plate.

If you're bringing home a new puppy and want to start clean, the habits in What To Do The First Seven Days With A New Puppy will save you this whole project.

And one last house rule worth keeping: whoever drops food cleans it up. Including Dad.

Wes Dunbar

Country & Skills

Grew up on an acreage and never quite left. Covers trucks, trades, land, and how to do the thing yourself.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Dogs & Pets.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Will Atherton Canine TrainingApr 10

    5 Dog Training Exercises You Should Do EVERY DAY At Home!

    American Standard Dog TrainingDec 27

    Stop Everything: Your Dog Needs These 5 Commands Now!

    Tom Davis Dog Training May 6

    Puppy TRAINING - The FIRST 5 Things To Teach Any Puppy!

    American Standard Dog TrainingMay 2

    Stop Yelling! Do THIS and Your Dog Will Finally Listen!