Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

The long-term care decision has a deadline, and it's your health

Medicare won't pay for years of help with bathing and dressing. In your fifties you can still choose how to cover that, and the window closes quietly.

By Ray Okonkwo · Money & Business6 min read
The long-term care decision has a deadline, and it's your health

Quick answer: Medicare doesn't pay for long-term custodial care, so someone pays: an insurer, your savings, or your family. Insurance only costs a sane amount while you're healthy enough to qualify, which is why the decision belongs in your fifties. Plenty of people should skip it and self-insure on purpose. Just make that a decision rather than a default.

What Medicare leaves out

Most people assume Medicare covers a nursing home. It covers a limited stay in a skilled nursing facility after a qualifying hospital stay, with copays after the first stretch of days. It doesn't cover the long, ordinary kind of care: help getting out of bed, bathing, dressing, eating, being supervised because of memory loss.

That's custodial care, and it's what most people end up needing. Check the current rules at Medicare.gov, because the details shift. The gap itself has been there for decades.

Medicaid does pay for long-term care, but only after you've spent down to strict income and asset limits. It also looks back, generally five years, at gifts and transfers. Handing the house to the kids at the last minute doesn't work, and it can cost you a stretch of ineligibility. An estate attorney who handles elder law can tell you how your state does it.

Why your fifties are the window

Traditional long-term care policies and the life-insurance-based kind both require health underwriting. Apply at 55 with decent blood pressure and a clean history, and you can qualify. Wait until 66 after a heart scare, early memory trouble or a bad back surgery, and you may be declined or priced out.

The people who most need the coverage are often the ones who can't buy it later. That's the one-way door in this decision. Self-insuring stays available at any age. Buying insurance doesn't.

The cost also climbs with age at purchase. A younger buyer pays smaller premiums for more years, which is a real trade-off, because you may pay for twenty-five years before using a dollar of benefit.

The three ways to cover it

Traditional long-term care insurance. You pay a premium, and if you need care, it pays a daily or monthly benefit for a set period. It's the most coverage per premium dollar. The big downside is that insurers have raised premiums on existing policyholders, sometimes sharply. And if you never need care, you've paid for nothing.

Hybrid policies. These attach a long-term care benefit to a life insurance policy or an annuity. If you don't use the care, the death benefit or cash value goes to your heirs. Premiums are usually fixed, which removes the rate-hike worry. The price is that they tend to cost more up front and deliver less care per dollar than the traditional kind. I'm describing a category, not recommending a product. If anyone pitches you an annuity as the answer, read What to Ask Before You Sign an Annuity Contract first.

Self-insuring. You earmark part of your savings for care and accept the risk. It costs nothing in premiums and every dollar left over stays in the family. It works only if the pot is big enough to survive a bad outcome.

A worked example

This is an illustration with made-up round numbers, not a quote or a forecast.

Say a year of care at home or in a facility costs $72,000 in your area today, or $6,000 a month. Look up real local figures before you plan.

Say you need care at 80, and you're 55 now. At 3 percent annual cost growth over 25 years, that $6,000 becomes roughly $12,500 a month. Three years of care is then close to $450,000.

That's the case where it goes badly. Many people need less, and some need none. A short episode of a few months is a very different number from three years of dementia care.

Now the part that matters most for a married man. If you need that care, your wife doesn't just lose the money. She also has to live on what's left for as long as she lives. Care for one spouse can quietly drain the other's retirement. The real question isn't "can I afford it for me?" It's "what happens to her income if this goes badly?"

Who usually should and shouldn't buy

Not an ironclad rule, just how the logic runs.

  • If you're comfortably wealthy, with enough that a few hundred thousand in care costs wouldn't change your spouse's lifestyle, self-insuring is usually the better deal. You're paying an insurer's margin to protect against a loss you can absorb.
  • If you have very little, insurance is probably unaffordable, and Medicaid is the backstop. Planning for that backstop is a job for an elder-law attorney.
  • If you're in the middle, with a house, a 401(k), maybe a pension, and a spouse who depends on all of it, this is where the decision is hard. A bad care event could take a big share of your savings, but you aren't rich enough to shrug it off. This group gets the most out of a serious look.

Other things push toward buying: a family history of dementia or stroke, a spouse with no income of her own, and not wanting your kids to become the care plan.

That last one deserves a straight word. Plenty of families do care for their own, and they should be honored for it. But it's a decision to make together, in advance, not an assumption that lands on one daughter. If you expect family to provide care, say so out loud, ask whether they can, and plan for who covers lost income and respite help.

What to do this year

  1. Price the problem. Call two or three local home-care agencies and assisted-living or memory-care facilities and ask what they charge. Write the numbers down. Costs vary a lot by location, which is one more reason to read What to Check Before You Retire to a Small Town if you're picking where to live.
  2. Decide your self-insurance pot. Pick a dollar amount you'd be willing to commit to care. Then see where it would come from, using Which Retirement Account To Spend From First as the starting point.
  3. Get quotes while you're healthy. Ask an independent agent who sells several carriers, then compare against what you'd pay yourself over twenty-five years. A fee-only fiduciary adviser can run that comparison without a commission riding on it.
  4. Ask about taxes. Premiums can be partly deductible as a medical expense, and certain accounts can pay qualified premiums, within age-based limits that change every year. Check IRS.gov and ask your CPA.
  5. Fix the paperwork. A durable power of attorney and a health care proxy matter more once care is on the table. Your Will Doesn't Control Most of Your Money covers the account-level traps.

Questions to put to any policy

  • Is the premium guaranteed, or can the company raise it? What's the company's history of rate increases?
  • What's the daily benefit, and does it grow with inflation? A flat benefit bought at 55 buys far less at 80.
  • How long does it pay, and is there a waiting period before benefits start?
  • Does it cover home care, assisted living and a nursing facility, or only some?
  • What triggers a claim, and how does the insurer verify it?
  • What happens to the money if you never use it?

Limits, ages, tax thresholds and program rules change, so confirm anything specific at Medicare.gov, SSA.gov and IRS.gov. This is general education, not individual financial, legal or tax advice. Before you sign anything, sit down with a fee-only fiduciary adviser, a CPA and an estate attorney.

You're not buying a policy so much as deciding who stands between your wife and a very expensive bad year. Make that call at 55, while you still have all the options.

Ray Okonkwo

Money & Business

Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Retirement.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    PJ Gibbs, CFP®Dec 15

    Retiring With a Pension - How it changes everything

    Erin Talks Money | Erin MoriarityJul 12

    Retirement & Pension: A Guide to Planning with Guaranteed Income

    Kevin Lum, CFP®Jun 22

    4 Things To Know If You're Retiring With A Pension

    The Money Guy ShowJul 13

    How Much Should I Invest If I Have a Pension?