Skip to content
BRO TakeEvergreen guide

The customer you dread costs more than the invoice shows

Some of your customers pay you less than they look like they do. Run the numbers, try a price first, and if that fails, let them go clean.

By Ray Okonkwo · Money & Business6 min read
The customer you dread costs more than the invoice shows

Quick answer: Work out what each customer pays you per hour once you count every call, text, redo and late payment. Raise the price on the worst one first. If they leave or the behavior doesn't change, fire them in writing, finish what's open, and leave things cleaner than you found them.

This is commentary, and general education, not tax or legal advice.

You know the name. It shows up on your phone while you're eating dinner and the whole table goes quiet, because they've watched your face change. Sunday night, you're already running Monday's conversation in your head. Your wife asks what's wrong and you say nothing, which is a lie, and she knows it.

That's the real invoice. Most of what this customer costs never shows up on one.

Do the math you've been avoiding

Take two customers. These numbers are an example, not a benchmark, so swap in your own.

Customer A is a property manager. He sends you six jobs a year and pays $18,000 total, net 10. He calls once per job. Your job time is 220 hours, plus about 10 hours of quoting and invoicing. That's 230 hours, or about $78 an hour.

Customer B owns rentals and also pays $18,000 a year. But he changes the scope halfway through every job, texts at 9 p.m., and pays 45 days late. Twice a year he disputes a bill. Say you eat $1,400 in change orders you never got in writing. Same 220 job hours, plus 60 more on texts, extra drive time, redoing work he reversed his mind on, and chasing checks. You collected $16,600 over 280 hours. That's about $59 an hour.

On paper they're identical. In your life, one of them is $19 an hour cheaper, and he's also the one who ruins your Sunday.

If you haven't looked at what an hour of your time is really worth, start with your seventy-hour week is a pricing problem. A bad customer is a pricing problem wearing a different shirt.

Do this exercise once. List your top ten customers. Next to each, write the revenue, the hours (all of them, including the phone), and the dollars you wrote off or chased. It takes an hour with last year's invoices. The bottom two names are usually a surprise. Sometimes the biggest check on the list is the worst deal.

Try the price first

Firing a customer should be the second move. The first is a number.

Quote the dreaded customer 25 to 40 percent higher than your normal rate. Don't apologize, don't explain, and don't pad it with a story. Something like: "My rates went up, and this job comes in at $X. Here's the schedule." Add what you're now requiring: a signed scope, a deposit, and payment on completion.

Two things can happen, and both are fine. He pays it, and now you're being paid fairly for the aggravation. Or he balks and goes shopping, and you've lost nothing you wanted to keep.

The price move works for customers who are expensive. It doesn't work for customers who are disrespectful. If someone talks down to your crew, swears at your wife when she answers the phone, or holds back a payment as a way to push you around, no price fixes that. Money doesn't buy a man the right to treat you that way, and you don't need to sell him that right at a markup.

Know which kind you've got

Some customers are just demanding, and demanding is a normal part of the work. A man who wants it done right, on time, and to the quarter inch is a customer worth having. Keep him.

The ones to cut have a different pattern:

  • They pay late as a habit, not an accident.
  • They dispute work after it's finished and after they've used it.
  • They treat you or your helpers with contempt.
  • They want a lower price every time and more work every time.
  • They've never once referred you to anyone.

That last one tells you something. Good customers tend to brag about you. If nobody he knows has ever heard your name from him, ask yourself what he's saying about you instead.

Fire them clean

Do it in writing. A phone call lets him argue, and you'll be tempted to soften it. A short email or letter doesn't.

Keep it plain: "I won't be able to take on further work for you after the current job. I'll finish [specific open items] by [date]. The final invoice is attached. If you'd like, I can recommend another contractor." Don't list grievances. Don't call him anything. The first sentence of your reply to any pushback is: "I appreciate that, but my answer is the same."

Then finish what you've promised. This is where you separate yourself from him. Complete the punch list. Honor your warranty on work you've already done. Return keys. Sweep the site, haul your debris, leave the place cleaner than it was when you showed up. Your name goes on this work, and the man who leaves a customer's house spotless after firing him is the man the neighbors hire next. The customer might gripe about you, but the job speaks first.

If he's referable, give him a name. If he's not, you don't owe one.

Before you send anything, check three things. Is there a signed contract with a termination clause? Do you hold his deposit or does he owe you balance? Do you have outstanding warranty obligations? If any of those are murky, spend an hour with a local attorney before the letter goes out. That's cheap next to a dispute.

Don't fire him until you can afford to

Backbone isn't recklessness. If one customer is more than a quarter of your revenue, you can't cut him on Tuesday because he was rude on Monday. Give yourself a runway.

Start filling the gap first. Call your best past customers and ask what they need. Before you pay for leads, call the people who already paid you lays out how. Put the work you'd have given him on the schedule for someone better. A good rule of thumb is to have replacement work lined up or enough cash to cover about three months of his share, then send the letter. If cash is tight, your January was decided back in July is worth a read about building that cushion before you need it.

If you're nervous, that's not a sign you're wrong. It's a sign you've been depending on someone who doesn't deserve it.

If it's more than rude

Now and then a customer crosses into threats, intimidation, or showing up uninvited. That's a different category. Don't go back to the site alone. Put everything in writing, keep the texts and voicemails, and tell your wife and your crew what's going on. If you feel unsafe, contact local police. No invoice is worth that.

What Monday looks like after

A month after you let the bad one go, notice what's different. The phone rings and you don't flinch. You pick up on the second ring because you're not bracing. Your wife asks about work and you tell her something other than "fine."

You were never going to get paid enough to make up for what that customer took out of the rest of your week. Sunday night belongs to your family. Get it back.

Ray Okonkwo

Money & Business

Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Self-Employed Men.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Martine Cadet Business ConsultantMar 6

    #8: Finding Clients as a Self-Employed Individual: Strategies for Success

    Daniel DimseySep 20

    5 Free Ways to Get Handyman Clients (Proven Strategies)

    Chuck the ContractorJun 26

    Contractor Lead Generation: How I Get Customers for My Construction Business

    The Handyman JourneyFeb 19

    How to get handyman clients? (10 proven ways)