Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Your hands can tell real wool, linen and leather at a thrift store

Tags go missing and labels fib. A few ten-second checks will tell you what's actually hanging on the rack.

By Dean Shaw · Gear & Garage5 min read
Your hands can tell real wool, linen and leather at a thrift store

Quick answer: Read the tag, then trust your hands. Wool feels warm, looks slightly fuzzy and springs back. Linen creases and stays creased. Real leather has an uneven grain and a fibrous cut edge. And if it doesn't fit through the shoulders, none of it matters.

A charcoal blazer on a thrift rack looks like wool from six feet away. From six inches it's often polyester with a good publicist.

That's the whole problem with thrifting for quality. The good stuff and the lookalikes hang side by side, usually under bad lighting, often with the tag cut out or worn to nothing. You can't wave a phone at it and get an answer. You have to know what to feel for.

Start with fit, then the tag

The order is fit, then fabric, then brand. A genuine wool jacket that pulls across the back is a very expensive lesson in wishful thinking. Check the shoulder seam sits where your shoulder ends, and run through the checks that tell you a garment actually fits before you fall for the fabric.

Remember what a tailor can fix. Sleeves, hems and waists are easy. Shoulders and collars are not. Pass on anything that's wrong in the places that can't be altered.

Now the tag. Look for a percentage. "100% wool" or "100% linen" is what you want, but 80 percent or better still behaves like the real thing. A little nylon in wool trousers is fine, since it helps them hold their shape.

Two warnings:

  • "Virgin wool" only means the fiber is new, not recycled. It says nothing about quality.
  • "Genuine leather" is real leather, but usually a lower grade than the "full grain" or "top grain" you want.

If the tag is gone, the checks below take over.

Wool: warm, matte, a little fuzzy

Hold the fabric up to the light and look at the surface. Wool has a soft halo of tiny fibers and a matte finish. Polyester suiting tends to be flat and a touch shiny, and it feels slick between your fingers.

Press your palm flat against it for a few seconds. Wool feels warm to the hand fast. Synthetics stay cooler and a bit clammy.

Then squeeze a fistful of fabric for ten seconds and let go. Good wool relaxes and the wrinkles drop out within a few moments. Cheap blends either stay crushed or look unnaturally stiff.

On a sport coat, do one more thing. Pinch the layer of fabric on the chest, just under the lapel, and see if it slides over what's behind it. If it floats a little, there's a canvas inside, which is how better jackets are built. If it feels glued flat, the interior is fused, and it'll bubble after a few cleanings. Fused isn't a deal-breaker on a ten-dollar jacket, but know what you're buying.

Then hunt for moths:

  • Tiny holes in the fabric, especially along the seams.
  • Thin spots at the underarms and elbows.
  • A bare, shiny patch that's been rubbed to death.
  • Little gritty specks tucked in pockets or under the collar.

Walk away from the first two. One small hole you can live with. A pattern of them means the garment is a snack.

Linen: it should wrinkle, and that's the test

Real linen wrinkles. If a shirt claiming to be linen comes out of your fist looking untouched, it's probably a rayon or polyester blend with linen on the label, or no linen at all.

Scrunch a corner for ten seconds. Linen holds the creases. That's not a defect. It's how the fiber behaves, and it's why people who wear linen well just accept it.

Look at the weave under light. Real linen has slubs, which are small irregular thick spots in the thread, and the weave looks a bit uneven. Machine-perfect, uniform cloth is a warning. So is a limp, silky drape that hangs like a curtain.

Feel it too. New linen is a little crisp and cool. Used linen should be softer, since it improves with every wash, so a thrift-store shirt that's already broken in is a gift. Check the folds and cuffs for fading or tiny splits, because linen that's lived in the sun can wear through along the creases.

Blends are fine. Linen and cotton is comfortable and wrinkles less. Just don't pay linen prices for something that's mostly viscose.

Leather: grain, edge and smell

Leather is the easiest to fake and the easiest to check.

Look at the surface. Real leather has an irregular grain, with small pores and slight variation, like skin. Faux leather has a pattern that repeats if you look closely, like wallpaper.

Press your thumb into it. Real leather wrinkles in fine, random lines around your thumb and settles back. Plastic-coated leatherette creases sharply or stays suspiciously smooth.

Find a cut edge. Inside a belt, under a flap, along a bag strap. Real leather shows rough, fibrous material, almost like suede. Faux shows a fabric backing under a plastic layer.

Then smell it. Leather smells like leather. A chemical, plastic smell is your answer. A sour, musty smell means mildew, and that's a harder fix than it sounds.

Shoes often have a stamp inside that says "leather upper" or "man-made materials." Believe it. Flip them over and look at the sole. Stitching running through the sole means it can be resoled. Glue and nothing else means the shoe's life ends when the tread does.

Skip these:

  • Leather that's flaking or peeling, which is bonded or coated material giving up.
  • Deep cracks at the flex points, like across a boot's toe box.
  • Dry, thirsty leather is fine. Dry leather with cracks is not.

Get it home right

Wool and linen need to be clean before they go in your closet. Skip the hot dryer for either one. The dryer is why your clothes wear out early explains the damage, and air drying solves it for free. Dry clean a structured jacket as rarely as you can get away with.

Leather wants a wipe-down, then conditioner, then patience. A good pair of boots and a decent blazer from a thrift store can look like a hundred-dollar purchase for the price of a conditioner tin and an afternoon.

Put them to use. A wool blazer, a linen shirt and a leather belt cover most of what smart casual actually means. That's an outfit assembled from a rack of other people's mistakes.

And when you find the real thing, a wool coat that fits across the shoulders, say, buy it. Nobody's ever regretted that one at the register.

Dean Shaw

Gear & Garage

Reads the warranty, the parts list and the long-term owner reviews before anything else. Trucks, tools, watches, and the cheap version that costs more.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Style.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Gentleman's GazetteNov 17

    The Most Important Fabrics in Menswear, Part 5

    Gentleman's GazetteNov 16

    Live: Lets Chat! (About Trousers and More!) #AskGG

    Gentleman's GazetteNov 15

    Small Talk Sucks! 10 Tips To Avoid Small Talk Tragedy

    AlexJan 15

    How to dress better without buying new clothes | Style Reset