Pick the file by what it leaves behind
Most guys choose a file by how fast it removes metal. Choose it by the surface you want when you're done, and the drawer gets a lot simpler.

Quick answer: Two things decide a file: the cut (the pattern of the teeth) and the grade (how coarse they are). For general steel work, a 10-inch mill bastard and a 10-inch second-cut flat will handle most of what you throw at them.
Walk into any hardware store and the file wall looks like a mess of options. It isn't. Every file on it answers two questions, and once you can read them, you can look at a piece of steel and know which one to grab.
The cut is the tooth pattern
Look at the face of a file in good light. You'll see one of four things.
Single-cut. One set of parallel teeth running diagonally across the face. It removes metal steadily and leaves a smoother surface. This is the file for sharpening, for edges, for anything where you care what the surface looks like afterward. A mill file is single-cut.
Double-cut. A second set of teeth crosses the first, so the face looks like tiny diamonds. Each tooth is a separate point, and the file bites harder and removes more per stroke. It also leaves a rougher surface. Use it to shape, to take off a lot, to knock down a weld bead or fix a bad cut.
Rasp. Individual teeth punched up from the surface, like a field of little spikes. It's built for wood, horn and other soft material. On steel it's the wrong tool. It skates and clogs.
Curved tooth. Milled teeth in a long, shallow curve, built for soft metals and auto body work. It cuts fast and clears chips well, so aluminum and brass don't gum it up.
The rule of thumb is simple. Single-cut finishes. Double-cut removes. If you only own double-cut files, you've been leaving scratches you then have to sand out.
The grade is the coarseness
American files come in a ladder, coarse to fine:
- Coarse
- Bastard
- Second cut
- Smooth
- Dead smooth
"Bastard" sounds like a joke and isn't. It's a real grade, sitting between coarse and second cut, and it's the workhorse of the lot.
There's a catch the labels don't advertise. The grade is relative to the length of the file. A 6-inch bastard has finer teeth than a 14-inch bastard. A longer file has coarser teeth for the same name, so don't compare a stubby second-cut to a long one and expect them to feel alike.
Needle files and small precision files use a different scale called Swiss pattern, numbered from 00 (coarsest) up through 6 (finest). Higher number, finer file. That one's backwards from what most guys guess.
Choose by the finish you want
A file doesn't just remove metal. It leaves a surface, and the next step has to deal with that surface.
Say you're fitting a steel bracket and need to take 1/16 inch off one edge. Start with a double-cut bastard. It does the heavy removal fast. When you're within a few thousandths of your line, switch to a single-cut second cut or smooth to clean up the scratches and bring it to size. If you'll paint or polish it, finish with the smoothest file you own and then move to emery cloth.
The mistake is doing all of it with the coarse file because it feels productive. You'll get there fast and spend the next hour sanding out the damage. Skipping the fine file doesn't save time. It moves the work to a worse tool.
Same logic on the other end. Don't start with dead smooth on a rough casting. You'll polish the high spots for twenty minutes and barely touch the low ones.
Sharpening is its own job
If the job is an edge, reach for a single-cut mill file, usually a bastard grade, 10 inches. It's the standard for mower blades, shovels, hatchets and axes. It's also the right choice for the rough work on a dull edge before you move to stones.
Clamp the tool so it can't move. File in one direction, away from the edge or across it at a steady angle, whichever suits the blade. Keep your angle consistent. Count your strokes per side so the edge stays even. If you're sharpening an axe, 15 or 20 strokes a side and then checking is better than guessing.
The file does the metal removal. The stone, covered in Raise a burr, and the rest of sharpening follows, does the refining. Don't ask a file to finish an edge a razor would envy.
Chainsaw files are a separate animal. They're round, and the diameter has to match your chain's pitch, which is stamped on the chain or listed in the saw's manual. A file that's too small rides high. One that's too big won't seat. Match it, don't eyeball it.
Technique that makes any file work
Push, then lift. A file cuts on the forward stroke. Dragging it back across the work dulls the teeth. Lift slightly on the return or just reduce the pressure.
Use both hands. One on the handle, one on the tip. Keep it level. A file that rocks leaves a rounded surface instead of a flat one.
Draw filing. For a really fine finish, hold the file with both hands at its ends, perpendicular to the work, and slide it sideways along the edge. It works best with a single-cut file, and the surface it leaves is finer than you'd expect.
Clean it. When shiny scratches start showing up in your work, the teeth are clogged. Those scratches come from a stuck bit of metal called a pin. A file card (a stiff wire brush) clears it. Rubbing chalk on the file first helps keep it from loading up on soft metals.
Put a handle on it. A file tang is a spike. Slip while you're pushing and it goes into your palm. A wooden or plastic handle costs a few dollars and takes ten seconds to fit. Never use a bare tang, and never pry or hammer with a file. Hardened steel is brittle and snaps.
What to buy and what to skip
Buy:
- A 10-inch mill bastard. It sharpens and general-shapes and does both well.
- A 10-inch double-cut flat bastard for removal.
- A 10-inch single-cut second cut, flat, for finishing.
- A half-round in bastard. The flat side does flat work and the curve gets into radii.
- A file card and two handles.
That covers a lot of ground. It's also enough to fit into the tool tote without making it heavy.
Skip:
- The big mixed set where every file is the same coarse grade. You'll end up with ten ways to remove too much.
- Files with no handle in the package, unless you plan to fit one the same day.
- Files stored loose in a drawer, banging against each other. The teeth chip. Hang them or give each one a slot or a sleeve.
The finish begins at the file
A fine finish later depends on what you leave behind now. Prepping a part for paint or an edge for a stone, the logic is the same one you'll find in Most bad finishes are actually sanding problems. The step before decides how hard the next one will be.
Choose the file for the surface you want. Then take your time on the last few strokes. That's where the difference shows.
Wes Dunbar
Country & Skills
Grew up on an acreage and never quite left. Covers trucks, trades, land, and how to do the thing yourself.
Watch
Worth an hour of your evening
More from Woodworking.
From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.
Read next
