Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Pick the game a stranger can play in thirty seconds

Mario Kart, Overcooked and Smash all run on one console and a few controllers. Here's which one fits your living room, and the setup traps that wreck game night.

By Dean Shaw · Gear & Garage5 min read
Pick the game a stranger can play in thirty seconds

Quick answer: Mario Kart 8 Deluxe for mixed ages, Overcooked for a team, Super Smash Bros. Ultimate for rivals. Each runs on one console, one TV and a handful of controllers, with no phones and no sign-ins once it's set up.

Picture it. Four people on a couch, one of them your father-in-law, who last held a controller when it had a single button. Whatever you put on the screen has about thirty seconds to get him playing. After that, he's either in or he's asking where the coffee is.

That's the whole test for local multiplayer. Ignore the review scores and ask three questions.

  • Can you explain it in one sentence?
  • Does a beginner contribute, or at least avoid being a liability?
  • Does losing sting for less than a minute?

Most games fail the second one. The ones below pass all three.

Mixed ages: Mario Kart 8 Deluxe

Four players, one Switch, and every Joy-Con works sideways as its own controller. A seven-year-old and a grandfather can both steer by tilting a thumb.

Turn on smart steering and auto-accelerate for the newcomers. Smart steering keeps a kart from sailing off the edge of the track, and auto-accelerate means nobody has to learn which button is the gas. Do it quietly, in the menu, before anyone sits down. Nobody wants to be told they're getting the training wheels.

You, the experienced player, keep the assists off. That's the handicap. You'll still win most races, and you should, but the item boxes hand trailing players the good stuff. A beginner lands a shell on the leader about once a lap. That's the fun.

The annoying part: the blue shell is real, and it will hit you on the last turn of the last lap. Take it like a man.

A team: Overcooked

This is the one that turns four people into a crew. You're cooks in a kitchen that keeps getting more ridiculous: moving counters, fires, a floor that splits in half. One person chops, one washes, one runs plates, and everybody shouts.

Nobody is playing against anybody, so the skill gap stops mattering. A kid who can only chop onions is still the most useful person in the room when the orders pile up. Levels run a few minutes each, so there's always a natural place to stop.

It can also start arguments. "Who left the pan on the burner?" is a real sentence that gets said in real living rooms, usually by someone who left their own pan on. Married couples should go in knowing that. If you want the same idea with less shouting, Moving Out has you hauling furniture into a truck as a team, and it's a bit more forgiving.

Check that the version you buy matches your console. It's on all the major ones.

Rivals: Super Smash Bros. Ultimate

Up to eight players on one Switch, if you own the controllers. Everyone's a cartoon character knocking everyone else off a platform, and the rules fit in one sentence: don't get knocked off.

Beginners mash buttons and win more often than they should. Good players hate that. Use the handicap setting and the game will even things out for you, and let the new guy pick the character with the funniest hat. It does more for the mood than any tournament rule.

Smash runs hot. If your house has a short fuse, set a stock limit, three lives each, so a game ends in a few minutes and there's no marathon to storm out of.

The small-TV problem

Mario Kart splits the screen when more than one person plays. With four players, each gets a quarter of the picture. On a 32-inch TV across the room, that quarter is about the size of a paperback.

Two fixes. Sit closer than feels natural, eight feet or less. Or lean on games that share one screen. Overcooked and Smash both put everyone in the same view, so they scale much better to a small TV. Mario Kart is best at two or three players on a small set.

The real cost is controllers

Count them before you promise anyone a game night. A Switch ships with one pair of Joy-Con, so that's two players. Four players means buying two more, and eight in Smash means a real stack of them. Whatever you buy, make sure it's made for your console. Cheap off-brand pads can lag in ways that make a race feel rigged.

And charge them. If you borrow a friend's console for the weekend, return it with every controller topped up, even if you got them half-dead. If you're the host, set them on the charger the night before so nobody's playing with a dying battery in the middle of the final race.

Do the setup the day before

Local play doesn't need Wi-Fi. Updates do. Nothing kills a Saturday night like four guests on the couch watching a progress bar crawl.

The day before:

  • Boot the console and let it update.
  • Update the game.
  • Make a profile for each player so nobody's stuck in a menu.
  • Run one race or one round to make sure every controller is paired.

That's twenty minutes. It saves the evening.

One last caution: skip anything that needs everyone's phone or an account. A lot of party games do, and the person without a smartphone or the patience to log in is the person you were trying to include.

Who the night is for

You'll be tempted to play the game you're best at. Don't. Pick the one where the quietest person on the couch has a real shot at winning. If you'd rather sit next to the kids than referee them, be player two instead of the referee. If you're worried about the evening running long, count sessions, not minutes. And if you want to know what else is worth the TV time, there's a list of the games worth your evenings.

Then find whoever said "I'm no good at these," hand them a controller and start the race. That's who the night was for.

Dean Shaw

Gear & Garage

Reads the warranty, the parts list and the long-term owner reviews before anything else. Trucks, tools, watches, and the cheap version that costs more.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Gaming.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Linus Tech TipsNov 21

    How to Start 3D Printing

    Linus Tech TipsNov 21

    GTA 6 on PS5 Pro vs Xbox Series S

    Linus Tech TipsNov 21

    GTA 6 on PS5 vs Xbox Series X

    Joey's Retro HandheldsMay 30

    Help! I just bought a retro handheld, now what?