Read the who, what, when and where before you read the spin
Most misleading stories don't lie. They answer the four basic questions in the wrong order. Here's how to spot it in under a minute.

Quick answer: Before you form an opinion about a story, write down who, what, when and where on a scrap of paper. Whichever one you can't fill in from the headline and first paragraph is the one to hunt for. It's usually sitting in paragraph nine.
Start with a headline nobody wrote
I made this one up for the exercise: "Man Dies After Police Encounter on Elm Street." Eight words. Read it and notice what you've already decided.
Who? A man. What? He died. Where? Elm Street. When? No idea. And "after" is doing the heavy lifting, because it lets your brain supply a cause without the paper ever claiming one.
Now picture the same story with the buried parts restored. The man had barricaded himself in a house for four hours. He had a rifle. The encounter began when he came out. Or picture the opposite: officers stopped him on a routine call, he was unarmed, and the whole thing lasted ninety seconds. Same headline. Opposite stories. The facts that decide it are the when and the how long, and they're nowhere in the eight words.
None of that is a real case. That's the point. You can't tell from the headline, and the headline knows you can't.
Write the four answers down
It sounds like homework. It takes forty seconds and it works.
Open any story that's got your pulse up. Read only the first two paragraphs. Then write:
- Who: named, or just "a man," "protesters," "officials," "critics"?
- What: an action you could film, or a vague verb like "clashed," "targeted," "slammed"?
- When: an actual date and time, or "recently," "this week," "after"?
- Where: a specific place, or "near," "outside," "in the area of"?
Any blank is a flag. Not proof of anything. A flag.
Then scroll. Find the paragraph that fills each blank. Note how far down it sits. A story that answers all four in the first three sentences is trying to inform you. A story that makes you dig for two of them may just be badly edited, but you should know you're digging.
Where the answer sits is part of the story
Newsrooms teach the inverted pyramid: most important fact first, details trailing off below. It's a good system, and it means that whatever a writer thinks is most important is what you'll see. It also means the fact that complicates the headline is almost always low on the page, because that's where complications go.
Take another invented lede: "Loaded gun found near Lincoln High." Read as a school-safety scare. Now suppose paragraph eleven says it was in a truck parked in a lot half a mile off campus, on a Saturday, and the owner was a hunter who'd come from the range. Nobody did anything wrong. The "where" and the "when" were true all along. They just arrived after you'd already felt the thing.
And it runs both directions. A story built to make police look bad can bury the standoff. A story built to make police look good can bury the fact that the man was unarmed. A story about a rally can bury that the crowd was forty people, or forty thousand. Don't assume the writer you distrust is the only one who does it. Every side's best reporters avoid it and every side's worst reporters use it.
Time has three dates, and you need all of them
Every story carries up to three clocks.
- When it happened. The event itself.
- When it was published. Usually stamped near the headline.
- When it was updated. Often in smaller type, sometimes missing.
The gaps between them are where confusion breeds. A "this week" story built on a ruling from fourteen months ago. A video shared as breaking news that's been circulating since a previous election. A photo captioned "file photo" in letters so small you needed to be looking for them.
Watch the soft time words. "Recently" can mean yesterday or last spring. "Since" is worse. Say a story tells you something is "up since 2019." Fine. Why 2019 and not 2018? Starting a count right at the bottom of a dip, or right before a spike, produces a different line than starting one year earlier. Ask who picked the starting date. You'll often find nobody can say.
Where is more slippery than it looks
The dateline at the top of a story, the capitalized city name, is where the reporter filed from. Not necessarily where anything happened. A wire story with a big-city dateline may describe events two hundred miles away that the writer got from a phone call.
Then there's the vocabulary of fuzzy distance. "Near" might be a block or six miles. "Outside" a building might mean the front steps or the far corner of the parking lot. "In the city" and "in the county" can describe very different crowds, courts and sets of rules.
Check the photo too. Captions tell you where and when it was taken, if you read them. A dramatic shot of a burning building is often from a different night, or a different story, or a different town. Real outlets correct that when caught. Our piece on how to tell which outlets actually own their mistakes covers how to read the correction.
The rewrite test
This is the move I'd keep if I could only keep one. Take the buried fact and drag it into the headline. Rewrite it yourself, in your head.
"Man Dies After Police Encounter on Elm Street" becomes "Armed Man Dies After Four-Hour Standoff on Elm Street." Does your reaction change? If it flips, you've found the leverage, and you know exactly which sentence was doing the steering.
Now be fair about it. Sometimes the buried fact turns out to be irrelevant, or the headline was cut to fit a space by a copy editor who never saw the full story. Sometimes the writer didn't have the detail yet at press time. Burying isn't always motive. Judge the pattern across many stories from one outlet, not one headline. The four questions an editor asks before a story runs is a good companion for that kind of reading.
Run it on your own side first
The test is worthless if you only use it on outlets you already distrust. Try it on the post your uncle shared, the clip your friend loves, the story that made you say "I knew it." That's the one where you're least likely to look for the missing date.
And when a story rests on someone you can't see, the drill gets harder, because the who is hidden by design. When an anonymous source is worth believing picks up where this leaves off.
Scroll to the bottom first next time. That's where the facts that didn't fit the headline go to wait.
Marcus Vale
Editor-in-Chief
Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.
Watch
Worth an hour of your evening
More from Media Literacy.
From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.
Read next
