Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Hand your daughter a bass. She'll fix your timing.

A short-scale bass, a four-note riff and twenty minutes a day. Why bass is the best first instrument to share with your daughter, and why she may pass you.

By Dean Shaw · Gear & Garage5 min read
Hand your daughter a bass. She'll fix your timing.

Quick answer: Buy a short-scale four-string bass and a small amp, and pick a song with four chords. Practice twenty minutes a day, and play along with her instead of standing over her.

A standard bass has a 34-inch scale. A short-scale has about 30. Four inches doesn't sound like much until you watch a ten-year-old try to reach the fifth fret on the long one. Her hand cramps, her shoulder hunches, and by week two the bass is leaning in a corner.

Get her the short one. That's the single most useful piece of advice here, and the rest is detail.

Why bass, and not just another guitar

You already own a guitar, or you're meaning to learn one. Maybe you've read about the first ninety days of learning guitar as a grown man. Then you'd have two people in the house fighting over the same job: chords, solos, the front of the song.

Bass gives her a different job. It's the instrument that holds the song up. Take it out and people can't say what's missing, only that the whole thing feels thin. That's a strange kind of power for a kid to have, and she'll feel it the first time she plays one low note under your strumming and the room changes.

The four strings are tuned E, A, D, G. Those are the same as the four lowest strings on your guitar, an octave down. So whatever you know transfers. Your A chord has an A underneath it. She plays that A.

Buy this, skip that

You don't need much.

  • A short-scale bass. The Fender Mustang PJ Bass and the Ibanez Mikro are both short-scale and common used. Ask the person at the music store to put one in her hands before you decide.
  • A small practice amp. Bass amps move a lot of air, and a bass through a guitar amp sounds awful and can blow the speaker. A little bass combo with a headphone jack saves your marriage and your ears.
  • A tuner and a cable. Clip-on tuners are cheap. Buy a decent cable once.

Skip the pedals, the fancy strap, and the second bass. Skip the "complete beginner kit" with an amp the size of a toaster. If a budget is tight, buy used and have somebody who knows basses check the neck for warp before you hand over the money.

The first song

Don't start with scales. Start with "Stand By Me."

The bass opens that song. It's a short, famous figure that repeats, and it sits over four chords: A, F-sharp minor, D, E. She can learn the pattern in one sitting and recognize the payoff immediately, because she's heard it a hundred times without knowing the bass was the reason.

Next, "Bad Moon Rising." Root notes, mostly, on D, A and G. Then "I Walk the Line." Johnny Cash's band kept a train-track rhythm under that song, and a bass player who stays steady on it sounds right. It's also a song about staying faithful to the woman you love, which isn't a bad thing for a father and daughter to be humming around the house.

Three songs, a few months, and she's playing real music.

How to teach it without hovering

Here are the basics, and then you stop talking.

  1. Plucking hand. Rest the thumb on the pickup. Pluck with the index and middle fingers, alternating, never the same finger twice in a row.
  2. Fretting hand. One finger per fret. Press just behind the metal, not on top of it.
  3. Mute. Teach her early to lay a finger lightly on the strings she isn't playing. Sloppy ringing is the number one reason beginner bass sounds like mud.
  4. Count. Put a metronome at 60 beats per minute. She plays one note on every click. It's boring. The boring is the point.

Then play your guitar next to her. Don't correct every note. Pick one thing a session and let the rest go. If you fix everything, she'll learn that practice means being corrected, and she'll find a reason to be somewhere else.

Twenty minutes is plenty. If you want a way to keep it from turning into a fight, read twelve minutes a day beats an hour of arguing. The same rule applies here.

Why she might be better than you

I'm not saying girls are born bassists. I'm saying the instrument pays whoever listens, and listening is a skill you can build at any age.

Guitar players get attention. They get the solo and the loud part, and a lot of dads who picked it up at forty are still chasing that. Bass doesn't work that way. The job is to lock in with the drummer, hear where the kick lands, and sit right there. Whoever wants to be the star will always rush a little, play a little louder, add a fill that nobody asked for.

A kid who's happy to hold the floor under the whole band can do that better than a grown man who's still auditioning. If that kid is your daughter, you'll notice it first on the day you're strumming along and she stops, looks up, and says you're dragging the bridge.

You will be dragging the bridge.

There's a long line of women who've done exactly this work. Carol Kaye is one of the best-known session bassists in American recording history, and the point of her career was making other people's songs sound right. There's a similar story across country music, and the women who built country music is worth reading together.

When she passes you

It'll happen sooner than you think, probably within a year of steady playing. Don't compete. Learn the thing she's doing and ask her to show you.

Then do the old-fashioned thing. When she's ready, put her in a room with a drummer. A church band, a school band, a neighbor's kid with a kit in the garage. Bass makes the most sense when it's playing with other people.

Teach her to leave the stage better than she found it. Coil the cables the right way, over and under. Put the stands back. Offer to carry the other kid's amp. A bass player who does all that gets invited back for years.

And when the band starts and she's the one who counts it in, step back and let her.

Dean Shaw

Gear & Garage

Reads the warranty, the parts list and the long-term owner reviews before anything else. Trucks, tools, watches, and the cheap version that costs more.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Music.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Piano Lesson with WarrenFeb 14

    5 Essential Gospel Piano Tips To Transform Any Song!

    Dion TodmanAug 10

    How to Play Gospel | Piano Tutorial

    Northern Rivers TalentJun 12

    Gospel Legend, Yolanda Adams, Teaches How To Sing Better

    Jeff SchneiderApr 24

    The Chord Game That Unlocks Jazz & Gospel Harmony