The tool for the job you keep putting off
An impact driver and a reciprocating saw both look good on a shelf. Only one fits the weekend you've got planned.

Quick answer: If the job is putting things together (deck screws, lag bolts, a shelf, a fence), buy the impact driver. If it's tearing things apart or cutting things you can't fit a bigger saw to (a dead limb, an old pipe, a rotted post), buy the reciprocating saw. If you can only own one and you've never owned either, it's the impact driver. It'll get used fifty times for every one time the saw comes out.
Start with the job you've been avoiding
Most guys shop for a tool the wrong way. They stand in the aisle and ask which one is better. Neither is. They do opposite things.
Think about the last three projects you put off. The sagging gate. The deck boards that have gone soft. The stump of a tree the storm took down. Write them down if you have to. Now sort them into two piles: things you need to drive in, and things you need to cut out.
That sorting is the whole decision.
What an impact driver actually does
It spins a screw like a drill, but when the screw fights back, it adds rapid rotational taps. Those taps do the work your wrist would otherwise do. The result is a long screw sinking into a 4x4 without you leaning your whole body into it and without the bit skating out of the head.
That's the selling point, and it's a real one. A drill will drive a 3-inch deck screw. It will also twist your forearm and chew the screw head if you get the angle wrong. An impact driver takes the same screw and doesn't care.
The annoying parts:
- It's loud. The hammering is a hard clatter. Wear ear protection if you're driving more than a handful of screws.
- There's no clutch on most of them. A drill stops turning at a set torque so it won't overdrive. An impact driver keeps going. Snap a small screw head off in soft pine and you'll learn this fast. Feather the trigger.
- It takes quarter-inch hex bits only. Buy impact-rated bits, which are usually shaped with a flex zone near the shank. Ordinary bits snap.
- It's not a precision drill. Fine for pilot holes in a stud with the right hex-shank bit. Not what you want for a clean hole in a cabinet door.
What it solves: decks, fences, framing, sheds, subfloors, hanging heavy shelves into studs, driving lag screws without a ratchet, pulling stubborn old screws that a drill would strip.
What a reciprocating saw actually does
It pushes a blade back and forth, fast, with a rough and ready attitude. You rest the shoe (the metal plate at the front) against the work, squeeze the trigger, and let it chew. It isn't pretty. It isn't supposed to be.
The saw's real gift is that it cuts things you can't reach with anything else. Flush against a wall. Inside a framed opening. Up a ladder at the awkward angle. Through a board with nails still in it.
What it solves: demolition, cutting out an old window frame, trimming a limb that's too thick for loppers, cutting through a rusted bolt or old galvanized pipe, chopping up a pallet, cleaning up a fallen tree for the burn pile.
The annoying parts are real too:
- It's rough. Don't expect a clean cut for finish work. Use a hand saw or a miter saw for that.
- It kicks. If the blade snags and the shoe isn't pressed hard against the work, the saw jumps. Keep a firm grip and two hands on it.
- The blade matters more than the saw. A cheap saw with the right blade beats an expensive saw with the wrong one.
Match the blade to the work
Teeth per inch is the number to read on the package. Fewer teeth, faster and rougher. More teeth, slower and cleaner.
- Wood, pruning, general demolition: a lower count, roughly 6 or fewer teeth per inch, in a 6-inch or 9-inch length. Pruning blades have wide, aggressive teeth.
- Metal pipe, bolts, nails in wood: a higher count and a bi-metal blade. The higher the teeth count, the thinner the material it's meant for.
- Demolition where you'll hit nails: buy a blade sold for demolition and expect to go through a few.
Longer blades reach deeper but flex more. A 6-inch blade is fine for most weekend work.
Where to be careful
Before you cut into any wall, floor or ceiling with a recip saw, know what's behind it. Wiring, water lines and gas lines don't announce themselves. If you can't see the back of the wall, don't cut blind. Check from the other side, or cut shallow and look.
Wear safety glasses with both tools. Clamp or brace what you're cutting. And keep a firm stance with the saw. It will pull you if you let it.
The decision, by problem
- Building a deck or a fence: impact driver.
- Hanging shelves or a heavy mirror into studs: impact driver.
- Pulling apart an old deck or shed: recip saw, then impact driver to pull the screws.
- Cutting back storm damage: recip saw with a pruning blade.
- Cutting off rusted bolts or old pipe: recip saw.
- A little of both, once or twice a year: impact driver first, borrow the saw.
Which brings up a rule worth keeping. If you borrow your neighbor's saw, return it with a fresh blade in it, wiped down and with the battery charged. He'll lend you the next one without thinking twice. Leave it better than you found it.
Buy the battery, not the tool
Pick one battery platform and stay on it. The battery and charger are the real expense, and the same battery will fit the impact driver, the saw and whatever else you add later. Most major brands sell tools bare, without battery or charger, at a lower price, so if you already own a platform, buy bare. If you don't, a kit with a drill, an impact driver, two batteries and a charger is often the better first purchase than two separate tools. The same logic applies to smart home kit that earns its place: buy into one system, not five.
Skip the cheapest no-name saw with no replacement blade source. Buy a tool whose blades and bits you can find at any hardware store on a Saturday morning. And skip anything that promises to do everything. A good pair of headphones bought for your actual week works the same way: the best one is the one that matches how you'll use it.
The honest version
If you only ever build and fix, the impact driver pays for itself the first weekend. If you ever have to take something out or cut something awkward, the saw pays for itself the first time you'd otherwise have used a hand saw for two hours.
Look at the list of jobs you wrote down. Whichever pile is longer is the tool you need. Buy that one, finish the gate, and let the other wait until the job asks for it.
Dean Shaw
Gear & Garage
Reads the warranty, the parts list and the long-term owner reviews before anything else. Trucks, tools, watches, and the cheap version that costs more.
Watch
Worth an hour of your evening
More from Gadgets.
From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.
Read next
