The kitchen drawer flashlight should be boring and ready

Quick answer: Buy a plain flashlight that runs on standard AA batteries, with one button and a tail that lets it stand on its end. Load it with lithium AAs. Check it twice a year. That's the whole job.

The power goes out at nine on a Tuesday. Somebody's kid is asking where the light is. You open the drawer, find the flashlight you bought three years ago, and click. Nothing. You twist the cap off and find a crust of white powder where the batteries used to be.

That scene is the real enemy. Not a dim beam. A light that was never ready.

The one

The type: a handheld flashlight powered by one to three standard AA batteries, about the length of your hand.

The spec profile:

• Power: removable, standard AA cells. Not a sealed battery pack, not a proprietary cell.
• Switch: a single button on the tail, or a simple twist head. One press, light on. No cycling through five modes to get there.
• Output: a couple hundred lumens is plenty for a kitchen, a hallway and a breaker panel. The maker's published runtime on a low setting matters more than the peak number.
• Stance: a flat tail cap, so it stands upright and bounces light off the ceiling like a lantern.
• Body: metal or tough polymer, with a water-resistance rating the maker actually publishes. Look for it on the box or spec sheet.
• Extras: a lanyard hole, nothing more.

Fill it with lithium AA cells, not the alkalines that come in the bundle.

Why this one

Batteries decide whether a drawer light works. Everything else is trim.

Alkaline cells are fine for a TV remote you use every week. Left in a flashlight for years, they can leak, and a leak can ruin the light. Lithium AAs are built for exactly this sitting-around job. One major maker advertises a shelf life of up to 20 years on the pack for its lithium AAs. Read the package on whatever you buy and go by that, not by me.

They cost more up front. Say a four-pack runs double what alkalines do. That's an example, not a quote. You pay it once and stop thinking about it.

Standard AA also means the replacement is at every gas station, grocery store and hardware counter in the country. A built-in rechargeable that's been drained to nothing in a drawer needs a cable, a wall outlet and time. You have none of those during an outage. That's the contrarian part of this column. The drawer light isn't the place for the shiny rechargeable.

The tail-standing feature earns its spot too. Hands free, light on the ceiling, you can dig through a fuse box or help a kid find a shoe. A pocket-sized light with a rounded end can't do that.

And skip the brightness arms race. I covered why in Lumens Are the Least Useful Number on a Flashlight Box. Indoors, a blinding beam bouncing off white walls just makes you squint.

What to skip

Strobe and SOS modes. If you have to cycle past them to reach "on," they're a liability. Panic and a mode menu don't mix.

Zoom-focus heads. The sliding barrel looks serious. It adds a part that can stick and a beam that changes when you bump it.

Four-figure lumen claims. You don't need a light that could signal aircraft to find the extension cord. More output usually means more heat and shorter runtime.

Bundle packs. A flashlight, three mystery batteries and a bonus keychain light. The batteries are the part you want to choose yourself.

Sealed-battery-only lights, as your only light. Fine as a second light. Not as the one that has to work after a year untouched.

Crank and solar novelties as the primary. Treat them as backups at best. You want something that lights up the instant you press.

If your situation is different

The cheap one is right sometimes. If you want a light in every bedroom, the nightstand, the garage and the mudroom, buy several cheap AAA lights and give each one a home. You're not betting the house on any single one. Put lithium cells in them anyway. A cheap light with a dead battery is just a plastic tube.

You run a power-hungry household. Rural, well pump, a week-long ice storm in the forecast? Add a lantern-style light that lights a whole table. Keep the AA light as your move-around tool.

You work with your hands. Under a sink, in an attic or at a breaker panel, a headlamp beats anything handheld. Buy one in addition, not instead. For the vehicle, the light belongs in the kit I laid out in The truck kit that handles almost every roadside problem.

You're set on rechargeable. That works if you'll actually top it off on a schedule. Pick one that takes a standard cell, so you can swap in a lithium AA when the charge runs out. If you won't keep a schedule, don't pretend you will.

Before you buy

Judge it by how repairable it is, not how expensive. Buy-it-for-life should mean repairable, not expensive makes that case, and it applies here. A light with a replaceable switch or O-ring and a clear warranty is worth more than a fancier sealed one.

Run down this list in the store or on the product page:

• Standard AA (or AAA for the cheap-in-every-room version), with the battery type printed on the body or box.
• One-button operation. Click it in the aisle if you can. Can you find the button without looking?
• A flat tail that stands up on a counter.
• A published water-resistance rating from the maker, not a vague "weatherproof."
• A published runtime on low, ideally measured to a standard the maker names.
• A warranty you've read: how long, what voids it, and who pays shipping.
• Owner reviews from a year or more after purchase. Search them for the words "switch" and "stopped working."
• Lithium AA cells in the cart alongside it.

When you get it home, load the cells, then back the head or tail cap off a quarter turn. It can't switch itself on in a crowded drawer and drain itself dead. Put a spare set of cells in a zip bag beside it. Tape a note inside the drawer: check light, May and November. Do it when you test the smoke alarms.

And if you borrow it, put it back with fresh batteries. The next person to open that drawer might be your wife, in the dark, with a kid on her hip.

Check the current price.