Which wrenches earn their spot and which just rust
A 150-piece set looks like value until you notice you've used nine pieces of it. Here's the short list that does the real work.

Quick answer: About a dozen sizes do nearly all the work. In metric, that's 8, 10, 12, 13, 14, 17 and 19 mm. In SAE, it's 3/8, 7/16, 1/2, 9/16, 5/8 and 3/4 inch. Buy those in good quality, and let the rest of the set be a bonus rather than the reason you bought it.
The set with the clean wrenches
A buddy of mine opened his toolbox last spring to show me a 200-piece set he'd gotten for Christmas. Every socket was bright. Every wrench was in its slot. Three wrenches had visible wear: a 10 mm, a 13 mm and a 1/2 inch. The other hundred-odd pieces looked like they'd just left the store.
That's not a story about a bad set. It's how tool use actually works. A small group of sizes does the job on bikes, mowers, bed frames, cars, grills and the plumbing under the sink. The rest wait.
The sizes that earn their spot
Metric:
- 10 mm. Battery terminals, brackets, covers, small hardware on almost everything. It's also the one that vanishes. Buy two.
- 13 mm. Probably the most used wrench size in a home garage. Bolts, nuts, clamps, flat-pack furniture.
- 12 mm and 14 mm. Brackets, bolts and fasteners on engines and chassis parts.
- 17 mm and 19 mm. Lug nuts on many vehicles, plus suspension and heavier bolts.
- 8 mm and 9 mm. Bike work, small covers, lawn equipment. You'll use them less, but when you need them, nothing else will do.
SAE:
- 7/16, 1/2 and 9/16. The workhorses on American-made equipment, trailers, lawn gear and older trucks.
- 5/8 and 3/4. Heavier bolts, trailer hardware, some lug nuts. Spark plug sockets often fall in this range too, though that's a socket job, not a wrench job.
- 3/8. Small stuff, and the one most people forget when they buy a short set.
Add an 8-inch and a 12-inch adjustable wrench. They don't replace the fixed sizes, because they round off tired bolts and loosen when you lean on them. But they cover the oddball and the one-off.
The sizes rusting in your toolbox
Look at a big combination set and you'll find the long tail. Wrenches at the very small end, like 1/4 inch and 5/16 inch, are rarely the right tool on modern hardware, and tiny fasteners usually want a small socket or a screwdriver anyway. Metric 6 and 7 mm often fall in the same bucket.
At the other end, the big ones past an inch get used a handful of times in a decade. The same goes for any size that exists to fill a gap in the set. If a wrench is bigger than your forearm and you've never touched it, you're storing steel.
I'm not telling you to throw them out. They cost you nothing to keep if you've got room. But they shouldn't change what you buy, and they're the first thing to leave your truck box when you're sorting what travels with you. The truck bed, cab and roadside kit belongs to the working sizes, not the whole set.
What a cheap set gets right and wrong
Entry-level combination sets from store brands like Pittsburgh at Harbor Freight, or Husky and Kobalt at the big-box stores, usually run somewhere between twenty and a hundred dollars depending on size and count. Prices move, so check before you buy.
What they get right: The sizes are correct, the finish holds up for ordinary use, and for a bolt you'll turn twice a year, they work fine. A cheap set is a smart way to build the full range for the occasional job.
What they get wrong: The jaws can be sloppier, so they round off a stubborn bolt sooner. The steel is softer. The box ends may be thicker and won't fit in tight spots. And if a wrench slips on a stuck nut, your knuckles pay for the savings.
The middle tier is where most people should land. Tekton and Gearwrench, along with Craftsman's current lineup, tend to sit in roughly the sixty to one-hundred-fifty dollar range for a full combination set. Icon from Harbor Freight sits near that band too. Snap-on, Matco and Mac cost several times more, and they're built for people who turn wrenches for a living. If you work on your own vehicles every few weekends, you probably don't need them. If you're a mechanic, you already know why you do.
Ratcheting wrenches, such as Gearwrench's, cost more but earn their keep in cramped spots where a regular wrench needs ten tiny swings. They're a good upgrade for the specific sizes you use most, not a replacement for the whole set.
Where to spend and where to save
Spend on the sizes you reach for weekly. A good 10, 13 and 17 mm will outlast a bargain set several times over. Spend on a torque wrench too. A click-type 3/8-inch drive for lighter work and a 1/2-inch for lug nuts is a sound pair, because overtightened or undertightened fasteners cause real trouble, especially on wheels.
Save on the odd sizes you'll use once a year. A mid-range or budget version of the 1-inch-plus wrenches is plenty.
And rent or borrow the rest. Many auto parts stores run loaner programs for specialty tools: you leave a deposit, use the tool, and get your money back when it's returned. That covers things like large axle-nut sockets, ball joint tools and big pipe wrenches. If a tool costs more than the job it's for and you'll never use it again, borrowing is the sensible move. The rent-or-buy breakdown goes through which is which.
Return a loaner cleaner than you got it. Wipe it down, put it back in the case, and bring it back before it's due. It's how the program keeps working.
A weekend plan
Saturday morning. Dump the toolbox on a table. Pull every wrench and sort by size. Set aside the working sizes above. If you're missing any, write them down. Toss anything rusted past saving, and soak the salvageable ones in white vinegar or hit them with a wire brush and a rag of light oil.
Saturday afternoon. Shop for gaps only. Start with 10 mm and 13 mm if you're short. If you've got nothing, buy a mid-range combination set instead of piecing it together. Add a second 10 mm.
Sunday. Give the working sizes a spot on a rail or a roll-up where you can see them, and the rarely-used ones a drawer. If a wrench has to be dug for, you won't put it back, and a missing 10 mm will cost you an hour. Where every tool goes walks through a layout that holds up. If you're short on space, the one-car garage shop layout is the one to follow.
Then fix something. A wrench that sits unused teaches you nothing. A squeaky bike or a loose rack on the truck will tell you right away which sizes were worth owning.
Dean Shaw
Gear & Garage
Reads the warranty, the parts list and the long-term owner reviews before anything else. Trucks, tools, watches, and the cheap version that costs more.
Watch
Worth an hour of your evening
More from Tools & Organizing.
From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.
Read next
