Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

The hem decides whether a shirt gets tucked

Most guys check the chest and sleeves and ignore the hem. That's why the shirt pops out by noon or hangs like a nightshirt.

By Dean Shaw · Gear & Garage5 min read
The hem decides whether a shirt gets tucked

Quick answer: Worn out, the hem should land around mid-zipper and never below the bottom of your fly. Tucked, the shirt needs enough tail to stay in with your arms overhead and your seat in a chair. Most shirts are cut for one job or the other. Find out which before you buy.

You didn't choose to tuck. The manufacturer did.

Picture the barbecue. You reach across the table for the tongs, and a foot of shirt tail slides out of your waistband and hangs there. You tuck it back in. Ten minutes later it does it again.

The problem isn't your belt or your posture. The shirt is too short to be tucked, and nobody told you because nobody checks.

Shirt hems are built for one of two lives. A dress shirt has long tails, curved up at the sides, made to disappear into your pants. A casual shirt, like a camp collar, a short-sleeve button-up or a lot of tees, has a hem that's shorter and straighter, made to hang out. Both are cut deliberately. Put one in the other's job and you get the barbecue.

The untucked test

Stand in front of a mirror with your arms relaxed. Look at where the hem falls.

  • Mid-zipper to the bottom of the fly: right. This is the zone where the shirt looks like a choice.
  • Above the belt line: too short. You'll flash skin every time you reach, and the shirt makes your torso look stubby.
  • Past the fly, toward mid-thigh: too long. It reads like a nightshirt, and it makes your legs look shorter than they are.

Straight hems and boxy cuts make this easier. A hem curved up at the sides, the classic dress-shirt shape, looks fussy when it's out. The tails flap, and a dress shirt worn loose with the sleeves rolled usually looks like you forgot something at the office.

Height matters, and it cuts both ways. If you're 5'7", a regular-length casual shirt often runs long on you. If you're 6'3", the same shirt rides up. Neither is a flaw in you. Shorter guys should look for "short" lengths or plan a trip to a tailor. Taller guys should look for "tall" cuts.

The tucked test

This one's harder, and it's the one most guys fail.

Put the shirt on and tuck it in. Now raise both arms straight overhead, like you're reaching for a high shelf. Check the waistband. If more than an inch of shirt has pulled out, the shirt's too short for the job.

Then sit down in a chair, lean forward and reach for something on the floor. The back of the shirt takes the worst of it here. A good tucking shirt keeps its tail even after that.

Two things help.

First, the shape of the tail. A curved hem with side vents gives you length in the back and front without extra fabric at the hips. A straight hem, tucked, puts a lot of fabric in a small space and makes a lump.

Second, the length itself. Dress shirt tails usually cover your seat for a reason. A shirt that stops at your belt line was never meant to go inside your pants, whatever the label says.

Fabric changes the answer

Fit comes first, then fabric, then brand. Once the hem is right, fabric decides whether tucking looks sharp or bulky.

Lightweight cotton poplin tucks flat and stays flat. A heavy flannel or thick oxford tucks into a roll at your waist, and tucking it can add a size to your midsection. If a shirt is thick and you want it tucked, size down the bulk by choosing a thinner version, not by cinching the belt tighter.

For tees, the same logic holds. A heavy cotton tee tucks into a lump. A thin one tucks smooth but can cling. Most tees are meant to be worn out, and the fix for a tee that won't stay tucked is to leave it out, as long as the hem passes the first test.

Knit polos sit in between. A good one has a slightly longer back hem and side vents, which lets you wear it either way. A polo with a flat, straight hem is built for out. If you tuck it, expect to re-tuck.

What a tailor can fix, and what they can't

Shortening is easy. A tailor can take a shirt that hangs too low and bring the hem up to mid-zipper in a short visit. It's one of the cheapest alterations there is, and it works well on casual shirts with straight hems.

Lengthening almost never works. There's no extra fabric hiding in the hem. If a shirt's too short to tuck, you can't add inches, and you'll have to buy a longer one. That's the one-way street of shirt shopping. When you're between two sizes or unsure, the longer shirt is the safer bet. You can always cut length. You can't grow it back.

Curved dress-shirt hems are trickier to shorten and not worth reworking on an inexpensive shirt. Better to buy it right.

Sleeves and shoulders are the real limits. A tailor can take in the sides of a shirt, but moving shoulder seams is expensive and often not worth it. If the shoulders are wrong, don't pay for a hem fix. Start over. The checks that tell you a garment actually fits walk through that part.

The shirts that do both, almost

A few shirts are designed to work either way, and they're worth knowing.

A casual button-down with a gently curved hem and a slightly longer back can be worn out or tucked, as long as it isn't too heavy. A lot of everyday oxford-cloth shirts fall into this group. If you're building a short list of pieces for the week, ten garments that get you through almost any week covers where these fit.

For dressier settings, tuck without exception. If the occasion is a wedding, a funeral or an interview, the answer is already decided, and what to wear to a wedding, a funeral and an interview covers the rest.

And for a half-way setting like smart casual, you've got room for either, but the hem still has to pass its test. What smart casual actually means is a good place to go from here.

Measure the one that works

You already own a shirt that hangs right. Maybe two. Lay your best one flat, button it, and measure from the base of the collar at the back down to the hem. Write the number down on your phone.

Do the same with the shirt that keeps coming untucked. Compare. That gap is the inch or two you've been fighting all year.

Next time you buy a shirt, bring the number. A tape measure takes ten seconds, and the store doesn't care. Neither does the shirt that stays where you put it.

Dean Shaw

Gear & Garage

Reads the warranty, the parts list and the long-term owner reviews before anything else. Trucks, tools, watches, and the cheap version that costs more.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Style.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Gentleman's GazetteNov 20

    You're (Definitely) Putting Your Pants On Wrong

    Gentleman's GazetteNov 19

    Live: Lets Chat! (About Trousers and More!) #AskGG

    Gentleman's GazetteNov 17

    The Most Important Fabrics in Menswear, Part 5

    Inspire StyleSep 26

    The Ultimate Guide to Business Casual (Upgrade Your Wardrobe!)